SMSF Market Valuations: The Cost of Non-Compliance (Part 1)
Updated: 6 days ago

Is near enough good enough when valuing SMSF assets at market value?
Not according to the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994
("SISR") regulation 8.02B, which states, 'Assets must be valued at market value' ("r 8.02B SISR"), and requires SMSF trustees to value all assets at market value when preparing financial statements.
The challenge is getting it right because the true cost of incorrect market
valuations can have financial, operational and tax implications for an SMSF.
What is a Market Valuation?
The first rule is that the market, not the trustee, dictates an asset's value. Adopting
a Goldilocks pricing strategy, where the trustee uses different values depending
on their SMSF goals, will result in a compliance breach.
The next logical step is to use the market value definition in section 10(1) of the
Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 ("SISA"): "market value", in relation
to an asset, means the amount that a willing buyer of the asset could reasonably
be expected to pay to acquire the asset from a willing seller if the following
assumptions were made:
that the buyer and the seller dealt with each other at arm's length in relation to the sale;
that the sale occurred after proper marketing of the asset;
that the buyer and the seller acted knowledgeably and prudentially in relation to the sale.
For clarity, the definition covers all types of property, including money. It
essentially expects SMSF trustees to make valuation decisions using careful
consideration and sound judgment, resulting in a fair and reasonable sale.
What Do the Auditing Standards Say?
SMSF auditors are equally responsible for meeting their professional obligations
under the auditing standards as under the SISA and SISR legislation.
Auditing Standard ASA 500: Audit Evidence is relevant for market valuations as it
requires auditors to design appropriate procedures to obtain sufficient audit
evidence.
ASA 540: Auditing Accounting Estimates, Including Fair Value Accounting
Estimates and Related Disclosures, requires auditors to assess whether the
trustee's estimates are reasonable and whether there is a risk of material
misstatement in the financial statements.
SMSF trustees are not typically experts or independent valuers. To that end,
auditors must ensure trustee estimates are prepared appropriately by reviewing
factors such as whether they used a reputable data source, their assumptions,
trustee bias, and subsequent events that can affect values.
In short, auditors need to understand how trustees arrived at a valuation by
evaluating the logic, information, and evidence behind it.
The auditing standards do not require SMSF auditors to obtain an independent
annual valuation. They need sufficient appropriate audit evidence on file to
substantiate the methodology trustees used to value assets.
ATO General Valuation Principles
The Australian Taxation Office ('ATO') market valuation guidance aligns with the auditing standards, as it also says an annual independent valuation is not
required.
A valuation is fair and reasonable if it considers all the relevant factors and
considerations that are likely to affect the value of an asset while using a fair and
reasoned process.
Trustees, however, must provide objective and supportable data as evidence to
support the reasons for their valuations. They must be able to explain the
valuation in terms of the methodology and evidence to an independent third
party.
It means that trustees are obliged to document what value has been adopted
and how that value has been determined.
The SMSF auditor is not responsible for valuing the asset.
The ATO has said that if trustees follow its guidelines, the valuation will generally
be accepted if:
It does not conflict with its general valuation guidelines or market valuation for tax purposes guide.
No evidence shows a different value was used for the corresponding capital gains tax event.
It is based on objective and supportable data.
Trustee Decisions & Market Values
SMSF trustees must decide whether to pay for an independent qualified market
valuation report. If they do, the Fund will be audit-ready.
Alternatively, they must provide objective and supportable data annually so SMSF
auditors can confirm compliance with r 8.02B SISR.
Trustees (or their SMSF advisers) need to allocate time and effort to obtain
sufficient appropriate audit evidence for their auditor. Where trustees cannot
provide evidence, the SMSF auditor may be unable to confirm compliance, and
the Fund may breach r 8.02B SISR.
Most importantly, if the ATO disagrees with a trustee valuation, it will apply an
appropriate method to an amended value, which can impact transfer balance
caps, non-arm's length income ("NALI"), a member's total superannuation
balance and the Div 296 tax impost.
It means an SMSF may be worse off where there are potential tax or compliance
issues.
Administrative Penalties
Breaching r 8.02B SISR can trigger administrative penalties. While r 8.02B SISR does
not explicitly mention them, it breaches the operating standards and attracts 20
penalty units, currently worth $7,280 per trustee.
Where a fund has a corporate trustee, the penalty applies once, whereas it
applies separately to each individual trustee. It is yet another reason to have a
corporate trustee.
Through its 2024 market valuation campaign, the ATO identified a high-risk
category of 16,500 SMSFs that reported the same market value of assets for at
least three (3) income years.
The ATO reminded SMSFs with more complex assets, such as residential and
commercial properties and unlisted investments in companies and trusts, to
report assets at market value every year. Otherwise, they may be subject to
additional tax and administrative penalties.
⏭️ In the final instalment of "SMSF Market Valuations: Breaches Under SISR 8.02B", we take a deep dive into market valuation requirements for specific assets and review a practical case study on how market value affects acquiring assets from a related party.
🎁 Bonus Resource: Download a copy of our SMSF Market Value Info Sheet



Comments