top of page

SMSF Market Valuations: Breaches Under SISR 8.02B Valuations (Part 2)

Oct 28
4 min read

Updated: 6 days ago

SMSF compliance breaches arise when SMSF assets have incorrect market valuations

In the second part of our series on SMSF market valuations, we focus on compliance breaches that can arise when an asset is not valued at market value under SISR 8.02 B.


Acquisition of Assets from Related Party

Some exceptions allowed under section 66 SISA, 'Acquisition of certain assets from members of regulated superannuation funds prohibited', enable an SMSF to acquire assets from a related party, such as listed shares, business real property, Regulation 13.22C SISR entities, widely held trusts, insurance policies, in-house assets up to 5%, or acquiring an asset from another fund as a result of a relationship breakdown or a merger of super funds.


To comply with section 66 SISA, related party assets must be acquired at market value, with an independent formal valuation undertaken as close to the transaction as possible, where relevant.


Acquiring assets from a related party below market value will breach section 66 SISA and may trigger the NALI provisions.


Case Study 1:

Scott decides to transfer listed shares to his SMSF as an in-specie contribution. He transfers $100,000 worth of listed shares at the 15 June 2026 share price and completes the off-market share transfer form.


Life gets in the way, and Scott finally signs the form on 25 August 2026. He sent it to the share registry that day. Does the transaction comply?


Suggested Answer:

While Scott planned to transfer the shares on 15 June 2026, the form was dated and signed on 25 August 2026. Because the share price differed on 25 August, the Fund breached section 66, which may be reportable to the ATO in the year the breach occurred if the ATO's reporting criteria were met.


NALI

Law Companion Ruling 'Non-arm's length income – expenditure incurred under a non-arm's length arrangement ("LCR 2021/2") discusses how purchasing an asset at less than market value incurs general expense NALI.


Where an asset is purchased under the terms of a contract in the fund's name and not through an in-specie contribution, any difference between the amount paid by the fund and the market value is not considered to be an in-specie contribution.


As a result, the Fund will trigger the NALI provisions, and all income from the asset and any capital gains on disposal will be NALI.


Case Study 2:

Scott decides to purchase business real property from an unrelated party. He personally pays the $60,000 deposit, which is treated as a non-concessional contribution. The fund paid the remaining $540,000 from its bank account. Does this comply?


Suggested Answer:

The purchase contract is in the fund's name, with the fund paying for part of the asset ($540,000), and the member paying for the rest ($60,000).


Effectively, the fund paid for an asset at "less than market value" by paying $540,000 for a $600,000 property, breaching section 66 SISA.


The fund has also triggered the NALI provisions because the asset was acquired under a contractual agreement and not through an in-specie contribution. All income from the property will be NALI, as will any capital gain on disposal.


If Scott, as trustee of the Fund, recorded the acceptance of the contribution in writing or on the purchase contract, and reported the market value of the contribution in the SMSF's account and to the ATO, the NALI provisions are not triggered (refer to Example 5, LCR 2021/2).


Collectable & Personal Use Assets

There is no requirement to obtain an annual independent valuation for collectable and personal use assets as long as the trustee provides objective and supportable evidence to show how they value the asset.


However, when the trustee transfers such an asset to a related party, it must be undertaken at market value determined by a qualified, independent valuer.


Each breach of regulation 13.18AA SISR, 'Self-managed superannuation funds – investment in collectables and personal use assets', such as leasing the asset to a related party or storing it in a related party's private residence, carries a penalty of ten (10) penalty units per instance, or $3,640. In this example with two (2) instances, the fine would be $7,280 per trustee, showing the true cost of an incorrect market valuation.


Loans

Loans are considered high-risk within an SMSF primarily because of recoverability. Required evidence includes a signed, dated loan agreement and evidence that it is on commercial terms, including the interest rate, whether it is secured or unsecured, and whether it is being repaid.


Where the terms of the loan agreement are not met, the question of recoverability and the market value of the loan is raised, which may result in a breach of r 8.02B SISR.


Complex Assets

Complex assets, such as property and unlisted entities, do not require an annual independent market valuation.


For property, the purchase cost at arm's length during the audit year is acceptable audit evidence, as long as there have been no significant changes since then.


If the value remains the same in subsequent years, the trustees must provide evidence each year showing how and why they have continued to rely on that valuation.


It dispels the industry myth that a property valuation is required every three (3) years.


Unlisted entities, on the other hand, require consideration of several factors, such as the most recent sale price between unrelated parties or a property valuation when a property is the only asset of the entity.


Issues arise when a different accountant prepares the financials. The reports are hard to obtain, and no other entity besides an SMSF is required to value its assets at market value.


Apart from the penalty units that can apply for a breach of r 8.02B SISR, all parties waste significant time, never to be recouped, trying to obtain objective and supportable data.


Market Valuations Conclusion

The complexities surrounding market valuations mean more onerous obligations and responsibilities for all SMSF professionals.


Incorrect market valuations can quickly affect SMSF compliance and have far-reaching implications for SMSF trustees.


With market valuations now a major risk area, SMSF advisers should expect SMSF auditors to be vigilant when reviewing documentation and valuations.


⏭️ Read Part 1 of "SMSF Market Valuations: The Cost of Non-Compliance", where we undertake a practical assessment of the requirements for acceptable SMSF market valuations by the ATO, SIS rules and the auditing standards.


🎁 Bonus Resource: Download a copy of our SMSF Market Value Info Sheet



Comments


bottom of page